Central bank policy: PRA and FCA float credit union reforms
A PRA-FCA paper asks if UK credit union rules are proportionate, floating lighter rules for small firms, flexible capital for big ones and a conversion path.
Central bank policy is usually discussed in terms of interest rates and balance sheets, but a large share of a central bank’s daily work is prudential: deciding how much capital a lender must hold, how much paperwork it must produce, and how those demands change with its size. On Tuesday the Bank of England’s Prudential Regulation Authority and the Financial Conduct Authority published a joint discussion paper that applies that discipline to one of the smallest corners of British finance, the credit union.
The paper does not propose final rules. It asks whether the existing framework “remains proportionate as the sector evolves,” and sets out a list of options on which the regulators want views. That list is worth reading closely, because it shows how a prudential authority thinks about the trade-off between safety and growth when the institutions in question are member-owned co-operatives rather than listed banks.
A sector with scale and an unusual brief
Credit unions are member-owned and typically focus on savings and personal loans within an occupation, a community or an area. The regulators put their membership at more than two million people in the UK. The paper builds on a joint report, the 2025 Mutuals Landscape report, which covered the wider mutuals sector, and the announcement also points readers to the PRA’s rules for small domestic deposit takers.
Both regulators framed the exercise in terms of access. The FCA’s Sheree Howard, executive director of authorisations, said credit unions support millions of members, “including many who may otherwise struggle to access affordable financial services.” The PRA’s Shoib Khan, director of UK deposit takers, called them a vital part of the financial system and said there is scope to make their regime “even more proportionate and growth-friendly.”
Two regulators are involved because the work divides along familiar lines. The PRA is responsible for the safety and soundness of deposit takers, which in a credit union means capital, leverage and the ability to absorb losses. The FCA looks at how members are treated, which covers products, fees and the use of outside providers. A paper issued jointly signals that the authorities see the questions as linked: a rule that eases the cost of compliance has to be judged both by whether the institution remains sound and by whether members end up better served.
Lighter rules for the smallest, risk-based rules for the largest
The options fall into two broad groups. The first is relief for small credit unions. The regulators ask about removing some requirements on internal audit and regulatory documents for smaller institutions, which they describe as cutting red tape without compromising stability. They also float applying rules designed for smaller deposit takers, such as a standardised approach to risk-weighted assets, in place of the simple leverage ratio that these credit unions currently report.
The second group concerns larger and more complex credit unions, and here the thinking is closer to bank regulation. One option is a risk-based framework with more flexible capital requirements. Another is a simplified version of the Basel framework, streamlining capital add-ons for large credit unions with specific exposures and adding a simple capital buffer to absorb shocks in stress periods.
This split reflects a familiar problem in proportionate regulation. A single rulebook tuned for the smallest institution constrains the biggest, while one tuned for the biggest burdens the smallest. A tiered approach tries to match requirements to business model, but it adds boundaries between tiers, and boundaries create their own incentives. A credit union near the threshold has to decide whether growing is worth the extra rules that come with it. The discussion paper invites that debate rather than settling it, and the regulators say the options give “more options to firms with very different business models, growth trajectories and risk profiles.”
Products, third parties and exit
The paper moves beyond capital. The regulators ask what barriers stop credit unions from offering new products and services, including how shared-service organisations and third parties could support investment, technology and operational capability. They also propose additional FCA guidance on working with third parties that provide important services, and they ask whether changes to FCA fees could reduce regulatory costs and support sustainable growth.
Two options deal with the shape of the sector rather than the cost of regulation. One would give credit unions a path to convert into building societies, a framework the regulators say is more tailored to specific lending and offers a wider range of funding tools. The other is a review of the solvent exit framework, to give credit unions more flexibility to transfer business or restructure in an orderly way.
Those two items matter for the long-run structure of the sector. A conversion route allows a successful credit union to outgrow the model rather than be held back by it, while a clearer exit path lets a struggling one combine or wind down without disorder. Both are also supervisory tools: a regulator that can see a clear route for an institution is better placed to guide it there before a problem becomes acute.
The mention of shared-service organisations is a quiet but significant detail. Small institutions often cannot afford their own technology, compliance or operational teams, and pooling those functions is one way to reach scale without merging. The proposed FCA guidance on third parties shows the supervisory side of that route, which is dependence on outside providers for important services.
What the paper does not do
A discussion paper commits the authorities to little. It records no decisions on capital, fees or conversion, and the regulators say only that they are encouraging firms to give feedback on the options and to suggest others that are not included. The test will come in what follows: which options survive consultation, how any thresholds are drawn, and whether the lighter requirements for small firms are matched by safeguards that preserve confidence in member deposits.
For readers who follow the Bank of England primarily through its rate decisions, the paper is a reminder that the central bank’s remit extends well beyond the policy rate. The PRA sits inside the Bank, and its approach to capital and proportionality shapes the sector’s capacity to lend as much as the cost of money does. The credit union paper is small in terms of balance sheets, but it is a clear statement of how the PRA and FCA expect to weigh growth, access and stability when they write rules for institutions that serve people mainstream lenders can overlook.
Prepared with AI assistance from public sources and reviewed under our editorial policy. Not investment advice.

